
Six weeks ago we watched as our country inaugurated the first African American as President of the United States. It was a hugely historic moment. Our emotions were stirred when we saw civil rights icons like Congressman John Lewis, weep as he witnessed what was once only a dream, become a reality. It was a moving, stirring day.
As I watched President Obama take the oath of office, I kept recalling the day a few years ago that I walked through the Lorraine Motel, where MLK was shot. It is now the Civil Rights Museum. My mind replayed like a video the images of slavery, of discrimination, violence and freedom marches, etc. It was a day for all those who struggled and were oppressed in ways I will never understand. And yet, I celebrated too. It was a day for all of us. It was a day for humanity. At the very least it was a day to put aside our politics.
However, that is what I want to write about. I am proud to say I voted for President Obama. But coming from a very conservative family and being an evangelical (although I don’t think I would really use that term anymore), I feel like I need to offer a defense of why I voted for the Democrat, and not the Republican. And in this process, I’ve also made some observations about the evangelical right that disturb me a little. So, this is my defense and my observations, not necessarily in that order.
I was raised in a very conservative, Christian family and environment where it was obvious, most of the time, that God was a Republican. The Republican’s were the ones who held to the moral values that we southern conservatives identified with being biblical. They were the ones who believed in the sanctity of life, sanctity of marriage, sanctity of the biblical (not) theme of pulling yourselves up by your bootstraps, the sanctity of …well most things conservative. And it was assumed that anyone who didn’t vote Republican probably wasn’t too close to Jesus and probably had some bad theology somewhere. The “other side”, the Democrats, were the enemy. And in this environment, it was natural to fear the enemy. I mean, after all, if God was a Republican, logic follows that they are of the Devil. And what would happen if the Devil were in charge? That would be the beginning of the end. And so we feared the Democrats and feared the world they would lead us to. So the Democrats, those “god-forsaken liberals” were not people to understand and work with, they were an enemy to defeat. Somewhere along the way, we conveniently forgot about Jesus’ command to love your enemies. Oh well.
But God is not a Republican. Nor is He a Democrat. He is God. He is bigger than all of this and more worthy to be praised for it. What I have found as I have grown, read, listened, experienced, etc. is that life is never as black and white as we would want it to be. Life is messy. The world is a fallen, messy place on both sides of the aisle. And in this context, there is good and bad on both sides. We can all make rational, maybe even biblical arguments as to why we, as followers of Christ, should vote this way or that. We must all vote our conscience. To me, there is nothing wrong with either choice. It is just that, a choice.
But being a somewhat more liberal evangelical (which I promise is NOT an oxymoron) here is why I chose to vote for a Democrat - simply because, I personally agree with more on their platform than I do with the Republican platform. Here are some examples and I’ll try to be brief (and no doubt speak in generalities that won’t be true across the board).
• I believe in the sanctity of human life. I believe that this issue extends far beyond just abortion (we’ll get to that in a minute). I personally believe that sanctity of life issues extend to homelessness, poverty, healthcare, the environment, as well as how we treat prisoners of war and whether or not it’s OK to torture them, and I believe on most of these issues, the Democrats are stronger. If life is sacred, and we are all equal humans created in His image, then we must be about all of these issues. If you wonder where the Lord stands on these issues, do a key word study on “poor” or “oppressed.”
Now obviously abortion is a huge issue and I do wish that the Democrats were stronger here. I hate abortion, I think it is murder, and I want it to end. But I also believe that while the right is dedicated (rightly so) to fighting abortion in the judicial and legislative realm, the right also ignores social issues (poverty, lack of education, etc.) that cause unwanted pregnancies and abortion in the first place. I want the right to succeed in making abortion illegal or at the least, much harder to get. But I fear that that day will never come. Abortion is sadly too much a part of our broken culture. So in my opinion, we must also do everything we can to decrease the number of abortions sought, which means we must deal with all of the social issues that send someone to the clinic. The fewer unwanted pregnancies there are, the fewer abortions there will be. The Democrats have a plan to decrease the number of abortions significantly over the next 10 years. And in our broken culture, I believe their plan will save more lives in the long run.
• I believe that the environment and climate are in trouble and we must take drastic steps to reduce the damage we have done, as well as to ensure our children have clean air and water. Even if global warming is not true (I believe it is – actions have consequences) I believe we still need vast improvement in being better stewards of the earth the Lord gave us. God gave us a mandate to rule and preserve the earth, not plunder and drain it of all of its resources. We are a consumer driven society that is ruining the world in which we live. Believing in the end times and that “its all going to burn anyway” is no excuse for waste and irresponsibility in the meantime. I’m convinced that is not what God had in mind. For more ideas and thoughts on this, check out the great book “Serve God Save the Planet” by Matthew Sleeth.
• I believe that everyone is entitled to healthcare and that if it were affordable, everyone who wants it would have it. I believe that a healthcare system can be devised that maintains our level of excellence and competitiveness, while being affordable for everyone. I’ve experience socialized medicine. I don’t want that. But I believe a great middle ground can be found. I hope I’m right.
• I believe that “spreading the wealth,” as Obama’s tax plan was called by the right, is actually a biblical concept. Here’s where I get it. In 2 Corinthians 8 Paul is encouraging the Corinthian church in their giving and says this, “For this is not for the ease of others and for your affliction, but by way of equality-at this present time your abundance being a supply for their need, so that their abundance also may become a supply for your need, that there may be equality;”
Now there is no time to exegete this passage here. But it is a good one to chew on. And there seems to be a biblical sense of equality here that in my opinion, is not on display in our current economics. The Bible says “to whom much has been given, much is required.” I believe this applies to our finances as well.
• And finally, I wholeheartedly agree with what President Obama said in his inaugural address regarding the size of government. I no longer believe that the question should be, “ is government to small or too big?” The question should be, “is government needed and how much?” Were it is needed, it should be. Where it is not, it should be removed. In this sense, I think the President is on the right track.
Now I could go on a little further, but I won’t. What I’ve written above is enough. And I know some will say I am naïve, or using passages out of context (I would argue the principal still applies), or haven’t thought things through well, etc. That's fine. I'm not claiming I'm right. And I'm willing to be wrong. This is just some of the reasoning behind why I made the choice I made. If you made a different choice, excellent. Let’s discuss. You are not my enemy.
And that is my final admonishment to the evangelical right, of which in many ways I still fall in line. The other side is not your enemy. Our enemy is not of flesh and blood, right? As followers of Christ are we not supposed to be known by our love? Can we seek to love those who disagree with us and open up honest conversations? I believe we can. Let us hold fast our convictions. But let us not hold so dogmatically to our persuasions and opinions that not only do we refuse to even listen or engage anything else, but we resort to fear tactics ("Obama is a muslim who hates christians and families!") and false judgements ("God hates fags!") to convince people we are right. When that happens, the church becomes known in the world as a place of judgement and in my opinion that does more harm for the Gospel than good. Let us approach anything with love first. I'm not saying we should avoid truth, not at all. But if we lead with love and humility I think we will end up with more of a platform to talk about truth, even in politics. Let us not live in fear of each other and the future anymore. Let us love. Let us seek to understand each other. Let us humbly be willing to listen. Let us work humbly together for a future that is honoring to our God. And yes, let us hope.
PS – Sorry for the length here. I guess it’s been too long since I’ve written and just had a lot to say.